Menu - Miss Amy's Bakery - Bakery in OH

Skip to main content Website Accessibility Assistance

Become a VIPBe the first to receive updates on exclusive events, secret menus, special offers/discounts, loyalty rewards & more!

Day-To-Day Offerings

$22.50By the dozen.
Soft sugar cookies topped with a fluffy vanilla bean buttercream rosette flower. Our house sugar cookies are generously sized!
Disclaimer: Decoration and color may vary due to supply availability. Standard buttercream color is white although seasonal colored buttercream may be available upon request.

2

2

$25By the dozen.
Scratch-made, quality chocolate chip cookies, made with only the finest chocolate. Made with love and crafted to satisfy the biggest cravings. Perfect for sharing (or savoring all to yourself), these aren't just cookies-they're a treat that's larger than life!

3

3

$23.70Six-pack
Classic soft chocolate brownies with three topping options. These brownies could feed 3 people, they are big! Flavors are: Triple Chocolate (topped with chocolate buttercream, chocolate ganache, and chocolate candy), Peanut Butter (topped with peanut butter buttercream, chocolate ganache, and peanut butter candy), or Powdered Sugar.
* Assorted Variety includes two Triple Chocolate, two Peanut Butter, and two Powdered Sugar Brownies.

Disclaimer: Decoration and color may vary due to supply availability. Flavor request modifications may be available upon request. (Example 3 triple chocolate & 3 powdered sugar)

8

8

$30By the dozen.
Our almond wedding white cupcake is a delicate celebration of flavor and elegance. Moist, tender almond cake with the perfect partnership of almond and vanilla bean extract topped with a fluffy, buttery vanilla buttercream. This cupcake can be topped with the sprinkle color of your choice or decorated with a white rosette buttercream flower. Please specify and we will to do our best to accommodate you!

2

2

$30By the dozen.
A moist chocolate cupcake topped with whipped peanut butter buttercream, draped in milk chocolate ganache and topped with a mini buckeye candy. This is every chocolate & PB lovers dream come true as well as a STAPLE at every Ohio State Buckeyes Party!

6

6

$30By the dozen.
A delicious chocolate cupcake with Oreo crumbles baked in, topped with cookies and cream buttercream, a velvety chocolate ganache drizzle, and a mini chocolate-dipped Oreo. (upon availability) These Oreo cupcakes go over great at birthday parties, work gatherings, family celebrations and more!
Disclaimer: Decoration and color may vary due to supply availability.

2

2

$30By the dozen.
They are filled. They are light. They are flavorful. They are our favorite! Cassata Cupcakes- A lovely white vanilla bean cake filled with both Italian mousseline cream and strawberry compote then topped with fresh whipped cream and fresh strawberries. If you haven't tried this cupcake, you absolutely should! Cassata cupcakes do require refrigeration.

9

9

Our same delicious cupcakes, that come in a variety of flavors, but catered to those with gluten intolerance! Our gluten-free cupcakes are crafted with care and attention. We pride ourself on using high quality gluten-free ingredients and recipes perfected for flavor and tenderness. While we follow best practices to minimize cross contamination in our kitchen, please be aware that we are not a certified gluten free only facility, and cross-contact with gluten ingredients may occur. We take every precaution possible to keep our gluten-free treats safe and scrumptious!Six Pack $25.50Dozen $42.50

5

5

$22.50By the dozen.
Soft sugar cookies topped with a fluffy white vanilla bean buttercream and sprinkles. Our house sugar cookies are generously sized!
Disclaimer: Decoration and color may vary due to supply availability. Our standard sprinkle color is gold but other colors may be available upon request!

0

0

$25By the dozen.
A customer favorite over the years. Scratch-made, decadent chocolate chip cookies with caramel bits and oatmeal throughout, topped with sea salt flakes. You will love this elevated flavor and never look at a regular chocolate chip cookie the same way! These cookies are generously sized! You won't be disappointed giving them a try!

2

2

$25.95By the dozen.
Indulge in the ultimate Italian dessert experience with our cannoli-crispy golden shells filled to the brim with a velvety-smooth ricotta cream that's just the right balance of sweetness and richness! Studded with chocolate chips for an extra touch of indulgence!

9

9

$42.50By the dozen.
Large chocolate eclairs filled with a delicious peanut butter mousseline cream, topped with peanut butter buttercream, peanut butter sauce, and candy pieces.
Disclaimer: Decoration and color may vary due to supply availability.

3

3

$30By the dozen.
Each day brings a fresh lineup of extraordinary flavors made from the finest, real ingredients. Our cupcakes are baked daily, our buttercreams are made with nothing other than real rich creamy butter-No. Shortening. EVER. Pure vanilla, hand picked fruits and high end imported chocolate are among some of the ingredients that set us apart-pure deliciousness. Every cupcake is a mini masterpiece, beautifully decorated to delight your eyes as much as your tastebuds. From classic favorites to daring new combinations, our flavors change daily, offering a new adventure with every visit or order. Indulge in the ultimate treat, where quality meets creativity in every luscious, bite-sized cake!
-We will select a dozen assorted cupcakes from our case that day. Please put in the special requests if there are flavors you prefer us to avoid and we will do our best to accommodate!

8

8

$30By the dozen
Almond white cupcakes filled with mousseline cream, topped with fresh whipped cream and berries. This cupcake is refreshingly light and extremely popular! People love filled cupcakes and our fresh whipped cream compliments this cake and delightful pastry cream beautifully! You definitely want to give these a try! Refrigeration required.

4

4

$30By the dozen.
Our most popular chocolate cupcake! This is the ultimate indulgence for chocolate lovers! This rich, moist chocolate cake is deeply flavored and perfectly soft, creating a delicious foundation for the buttery vanilla bean buttercream dunked in silky smooth milk chocolate ganache topped with a swirl of chocolate buttercream and chocolate curls. A simple, elegant cupcake that delivers pure satisfaction.

6

6

$30By the dozen.
This is a contender for our most popular flavor! A light almond white cupcake with a fabulous raspberry compote swirled and baked in, topped with a vanilla buttercream rosette flower or vanilla buttercream and fresh raspberry. Please specify your preference of topping.

4

4

Featured

Our soft and creamy classic New York Style cheesecake with a honey graham cracker crust that practically melts in your mouth. This comes in several specialty flavors or can be topped with one of our delicious fruit compotes or ganache. The 10 inch serves 14-16 people and the 6 inch serves 6-8 people.6 Inch $3310 Inch $55

11

11

Show All Items

GF

Gluten-Free