Building Your Custom Cake
We offer a wide selection of cake flavors and can cater to any design you have in mind! Simply follow the four steps below to place your order!
Custom Cakes
Step 1
CHOOSE YOUR CAKE SIZE
Round Cakes
• 6-INCH ROUND DOUBLE-LAYER, SERVES 8-12* – FROM $40
- TRIPLE-LAYER, SERVES 12-18 – FROM $55
• 8-INCH ROUND DOUBLE-LAYER, SERVES 15-18* – FROM $55
- TRIPLE-LAYER, SERVES 20-25 – FROM $86
• 9-INCH ROUND DOUBLE-LAYER, SERVES 18-25* – FROM $86
- TRIPLE-LAYER, SERVES 28-34 – FROM $114
• 10-INCH ROUND DOUBLE-LAYER, SERVES 25-31* – FROM $92
- TRIPLE-LAYER, SERVES 35-40 – FROM $128
Our cake servings are generously sized-larger than most!
Tiered Cakes : Please call in to discuss custom design and pricing.
Step 2
CHOOSE A FLAVOR, FROSTING, AND FILLING
Flavor Options
• Almond Wedding Cake
• White Raspberry Cheesecake
• Confetti Birthday Cake
• White Strawberry Cassata Cake
• Old Fashioned Yellow
• Chocolate Chip
• Banana Cream Pie
• Strawberries and Cream
• Lemon
• Lemon Raspberry
• Strawberry Lemonade
• Chocolate with Ganache
• Buckeye
• Triple Chocolate
• Red Velvet
• Reeses Cup
• Oreos and Cream
• Chocolate Caramel
• Chocolate Cheesecake
• Marble
• HoHo Cake
• French Silk Pie
• German Chocolate
• Nutter Butter Chip
• Andes Mint
• Carrot Cake
• S’mores
• Spice Cake
• Pumpkin Cheesecake
• Chocolate Peppermint
• Cookie Dough
• White Chocolate Candy Cane
Frosting Options
• White Buttercream
• Chocolate Buttercream (brown color)
• Peanut Butter Buttercream (tan color)
• Cream Cheese Buttercream (may limit decoration)
• Whipped Cream (may limit decoration)
Filling Options
• Any Frosting Listed Above
• Fruit Compotes
- Strawberry
- Blueberry
- Raspberry
- Guava
- Apple
- Peach
- Lemon Curd
- Chocolate Ganache
- Caramel Ganache
- Mousseline Cream (Italian Pastry Cream)
Step 3
KNOW HOW YOU WANT YOUR CAKE DECORATED
Visit our “Recent Work” page to view our cake catalog. If you have pictures for inspiration, send them to missamysbakerypics@gmail.com AFTER completing step #4.
Step 4
PLACE YOUR ORDER!
Call us at 330-804-0000 and choose option 4 or stop into our shop to place your order. Please understand that your order is not placed until you have spoken with one of our team members. We do not take order confirmation via email or voicemail.
An important note...
Due to a high influx of orders, we often have dates book up quickly for custom cakes, especially around holidays and when we have large events. Also, please understand that your order is not placed until you have spoken with one of our team members either in person or over the phone. We do not take order confirmation via email or voicemail.
